Tata Motors is one of the leading automobile manufacturers in India and a pioneer of the electric vehicle (EV) evolution in the country. The company has launched several EV models such as the Nexon EV, the Tigor EV and the Tiago EV. The Tiago EV is the latest addition to the Tata EV family and was launched on 28 September 2022. The Tiago EV is a hatchback that offers a stylish design, a comfortable cabin, a competitive price point and an eco-friendly drive experience. Here we are going to compare two ev’s from Tata Motors Tiago EV vs Tata Punch EV.
But Tata Motors is not stopping there. The company has also hinted at launching another EV model soon, the Punch EV. The Punch EV will be based on the same ALFA-tech platform as the Tiago EV but will be a sub-compact SUV with more space, features and performance. The Punch EV is expected to launch by February 2024.
Contents
Tata Tiago EV vs Tata Punch EV: Which one to buy?
So, if you are looking for an EV from Tata Motors, which one should you buy? The Tiago EV or the Punch EV? Let’s compare them on some key parameters and find out.
Design
| Parameter | Tiago EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Body style | Hatchback | Sub-compact SUV |
| Grille | Blanked-off with tri-arrow pattern and electric-blue inserts | Blanked-off with tri-arrow pattern and electric-blue inserts |
| Wheels | R14 hyperstyle wheels | Squared-out wheel arches |
| Roof | Contrast roof | Contrast roof |
| Door handles | Body colour with piano black insert | Body colour with piano black insert |
| Upholstery | Leatherette | Fabric |
The Tiago EV and the Punch EV have different body styles but share some common design elements. Both have a blanked-off grille with the signature tri-arrow pattern and electric-blue inserts. Both also have projector headlamps, daytime running lamps (DRLs), contrast roof and body colour door handles with piano black insert.
The Tiago EV has a sporty and sleek look with R14 hyperstyle wheels, .EV front grill and leatherette upholstery. The Punch EV has a rugged and muscular look with squared-out wheel arches, wrap-around taillights and chrome inner door handle.
Performance
| Parameter | Tiago EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Battery pack options | 19.2 kWh and 24 kWh | Unknown |
| Claimed range | 250 km and 315 km | Around 350 km |
| Power output | 60 bhp/110 Nm and 74 bhp/114 Nm | Higher than Nexon EV (127 bhp/245 Nm) |
| Acceleration (0 to 60 km/h) | 5.7 seconds | Unknown |
| Drive modes | Eco, City and Sport | Unknown |
The Tiago EV and the Punch EV are powered by different battery packs and electric motors. The Tiago EV comes with two battery pack options: 19.2 kWh and 24 kWh, with a claimed range of 250 km and 315 km, respectively. The former makes 60 bhp/110 Nm, while the latter produces 74 bhp/114 Nm. The Tiago EV can accelerate from 0 to 60 km/h in 5.7 seconds and has three drive modes: Eco, City and Sport.
The Punch EV is expected to use the same Ziptron electric motor as the Nexon EV but with slightly different tuning and higher power output figures. The Punch EV could have a range of around 350 km and could also have multiple drive modes and regenerative braking.
Charging
| Parameter | Tiago EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Home wall box charger options | 3.3 kW or 7.2 kW | Unknown |
| DC fast charging time (10 to 80 per cent) | 57 minutes | Around an hour |
| Portable charger option | Yes (15 A) | Unknown |
The Tiago EV and the Punch EV come with different charging options depending on the variant. The Tiago EV comes with either a 3.3 kW or 7.2 kW home wall box charger. With DC fast charging, it can be charged from 10 to 80 per cent in a claimed 57 minutes. It also comes with a 15 A portable charger that can charge from any socket.
The Punch EV could have similar charging options as the Nexon EV, which comes with a 3.3 kW home charger that can charge from 20 to 80 per cent in eight hours. It also supports DC fast charging that can charge from zero to 80 per cent in an hour.
Features
| Parameter | Tiago EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Touchscreen infotainment system | 7-inch by Harman with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay | 7-inch by Harman with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay |
| Digital instrument cluster | Yes | Yes |
| Automatic climate control | Yes | Yes |
| Cruise control | Yes | Yes |
| Cooled glovebox | Yes | Yes |
| Flat bottom steering wheel with mounted controls | Yes | Yes |
| Reverse parking camera with sensors | Yes | Yes |
| ZConnect features with smartwatch compatibility | 45 | Unknown |
| Speakers and tweeters | 4 each | 14 by Meridian |
| Electric auto fold ORVMs | Yes | Unknown |
| Powered boot opening | Yes | Unknown |
| Tire puncture repair kit | Yes | Unknown |
| ADAS (Advanced Driver Assist System) | No | Yes |
| Tata connect | No | Yes |
| TPMS | No | Yes |
The Tiago EV and the Punch EV are loaded with features that enhance functionality and driving pleasure. Both come with a 7-inch touchscreen infotainment system by Harman with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay support , a digital instrument cluster , automatic climate control , cruise control , cooled glovebox , flat bottom steering wheel with mounted controls and reverse parking camera with sensors .
The Tiago EV also comes with 45 ZConnect features with smartwatch compatibility, four speakers and four tweeters, electric auto fold ORVMs, powered boot opening and tire puncture repair kit. The Punch EV also comes with ADAS (Advanced Driver Assist System), Tata connect, a 14-speaker Meridian surround sound system and TPMS.
Safety
| Parameter | Tiago EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Architecture | ALFA (Agile Light Flexible Advanced) | ALFA (Agile Light Flexible Advanced) |
| Standard safety features | Dual front airbags, ABS with EBD and corner stability control, child seat ISOFIX anchor points and perimetric alarm system | Dual front airbags, ABS with EBD and corner stability control, child seat ISOFIX anchor points and perimetric alarm system |
| Global NCAP rating | 4 stars for adult and child occupant protection | Unknown (could be similar or higher than Tiago EV) |
| Additional safety features | None | Hill hold control, hill descent control, traction control, electronic stability program and rollover mitigation |
The Tiago EV and the Punch EV are built on the ALFA architecture, which is designed to provide high structural strength and rigidity. Both also come with standard safety features such as dual front airbags, ABS with EBD and corner stability control, child seat ISOFIX anchor points and perimetric alarm system .
The Tiago EV has a 4-star rating from Global NCAP for adult and child occupant protection. The Punch EV could also have a similar or higher rating as it is expected to come with additional safety features such as hill hold control, hill descent control, traction control, electronic stability program and rollover mitigation.
Price – Tiago EV vs Tata Punch EV
| Parameter | Tiago EV | Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Ex-showroom price range (all-India) | Rs. 8.69 lakh to Rs. 12.04 lakh | Rs. 11.23 lakh to Rs. 13.97 lakh (estimated) |
The Tiago EV is priced between Rs. 8.69 lakh and Rs. 12.04 lakh (ex-showroom, all-India). The Punch EV is expected to be priced between Rs. 11.23 lakh and Rs. 13.97 lakh (ex-showroom).
Conclusion
The Tiago EV and the Punch EV are both promising EV models from Tata Motors that offer different benefits to the customers. The Tiago EV is a hatchback that offers a stylish design, a comfortable cabin, a competitive price point and an eco-friendly drive experience. The Punch EV is a sub-compact SUV that offers more space, features and performance.
Also Read This : Upcoming Tata Punch EV vs Current Tata Punch